this post was submitted on 24 Oct 2023
1 points (100.0% liked)
Photography
24 readers
1 users here now
A place to politely discuss the tools, technique and culture of photography.
This is not a good place to simply share cool photos/videos or promote your own work and projects, but rather a place to discuss photography as an art and post things that would be of interest to other photographers.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I think what works for you isn't universal and vice versa.
You say that there are settings pros don't know about, but how would someone know about it unless they hear it from someone? I've learned about new settings from various youtubers and people on this sub. Similiarly, when I go out and photograph, I'll come back and think "How could I have done better", then go to youtube or fellow photographers for improvements on what I want to work on.
It's weird that you say that YouTubers are ruining photography and then specifically mention Peter McKinnon, a youtuber that's practically a joke in this and the videography sub for creating a unique but generic style that a lot of beginners try to copy before finding their own style.
Truth.
I must have worded the title better. Youtube is ruining photography for beginners or people who are starting out.
Like... as a pro I can watch a video, and get the info I want, and ignore what I don't want.
But beginners, as you mentioned try to copy the pros and that usually stops their creativity.
Also I mentioned Peter Mckinnon because he, himself is a good photographer as you mentioned. But again my point was people shouldn't rely too much on what they say when it comes to photography, if you're a beginner.
But you still mentioned Peter McKinnon, not as as a good photographer, but as a good Youtube photographer which contradicts your point.
Also, there's YouTube is the way people learn a skill for free. Not everyone can take a classes. I started photography seriously seven years ago and learn the basics through youtube. When I wanted to take portraits outside, I went to youtube; when I wanted to understand time lapse, youtube. Yes, there will always be beginners that fall into the traps of "Gotta get that sweet bokeh *kiss* goodness" but they're still learning the basics.
You think YouTube is ruining new photographers, good for you, but your experience isn't universal and the fact you say that while also praising Peter McKinnon, the BIGGEST and most overhyped photographer on the platform just shows it's your opinion. If someone wants to learn photography, I'll be quick to point out a few youtube videos that illustrate lighting and composition.
As I mentioned Peter McKinnon is a good content creator. And I picked him as my example cause as you mentioned he is the biggest. People with no photography experience can watch his videos and enjoy. Which is why he is a content creator. And it’s fine to watch such content creators, enjoy, maybe get inspired by them.
Going a step further and copying them step by step (which most beginners do) is what’s ruining their creativity.