this post was submitted on 19 Apr 2024
38 points (100.0% liked)
British Columbia
1364 readers
15 users here now
News, highlights and more relating to this great province!
founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Honest question: isn't having the First Nation blessing violating the same constitution that the prayer is? Obviously the prayer is an obvious violation, but replacing it doesn't seem to be the answer as far as I can tell.
First Nations blessing is a bit of a gray area because they are not necessarily performed as a religious practice. Instead of a prayer, it’s interpreted (by those present) more like a First Nations representative formally acknowledging that the decisions about to be made are made with their participation.
It’s a cultural complexity that elders are often also seen as religious leaders and they’ll often speak in religious terms, but their blessing is foremost under the guise of a representative - not a cleric.
As for a regular Christian prayer… its sole purpose is a ritual for those in that religion.
Ah thanks, this makes a lot more sense!
I would say it's because our white-man* laws came after, and the typical indigenous pretext at meetings is acknowledging that we are gathered on the unceded territory. So really they are letting us have a meeting with their blessing/permission.
Also they say unceded as a nice way; instead of juat saying stolen with acts of genocide.
*or woman ~ Monty Python
What's weird is the video doesn't show it, and the article doesn't quote it. That said, I think if anything, it's a fantastic compromise. Now not only are we removing direct religious action, we're replacing it with something that helps with reconciliation.
I would also argue there's a pretty large difference between people in power using their own religion to open an event like this, and people in power giving space to those without power to open an event.
It's because it's not religion, it's spiritually and culture. Shit bro most of them doing the things are Christians or Catholic