You can’t name a single headphone that has consistent reviews here. And not only that the reviews aren’t consistent, they are compeletly in contrast to each other and you can’t get any useful info on products because of that. I’ve been looking around for a headphone that i can upgrade to and after 2 weeks of watching reviews on YT and reading people’s opinions here, I am pretty much convinced that there is no point in reading nor watching the reviews here and YT.
I also do not understand the overly negative feelings people have towards different headphones. It almost feels like 75 percent of reviewers here are just fan-boys of a single brand and are trying to destroy other headphone brands.
And I’ve been into the hobby for about 4 years now and I know the terms people use and what they by them, so no I’m not confused by terminology or anything like that, I’m just frustrated by everyone here thinking they are absolutely right about everything (sometimes even about things they haven’t even tried)
Think of headphone reviews like restaurant reviews. On any restaurant, you're going to find people with different views on how good that restaurant is. Some will say "this is the best German food I've had!" and others will say "this food was terrible!" Or some reviews say "this dish was too spicy", and others will say "this [same] dish was perfectly spiced". Same deal with quality of service, with some people saying the service is great and others saying it's terrible. Some people don't care about service, others deduct two stars because "food was wonderful, but the waitress didn't smile. 3/5 stars."
Reviews are good for both restaurants and headphones, as someone else said, to calibrate expectations. If I see a restaurant has many reviews saying how their Peking duck is great, I'll probably try it for its Peking duck. I'm not actually that big a fan of Peking duck to begin with though, so I'll probably try other restaurants first. Same thing with headphones; if many people like the mids on one headphone, I'll probably check it out if I want to listen to a mid-centric presentation.
Lol the restaurant review analogy is apt, since with both restaurants and headphones you can infer whether you'll like it even with the vocally bad reviews. Chinese restaurant rated 4 stars, tons of reviews saying rude service, food is too spicy and greasy? That food will be amazing. Someone with HE4XX and Stellaris on their flair complaining about some cans being too laid-back? I'm gonna love that shit.