FerNZA

joined 1 year ago
[–] FerNZA@lemmy.world 2 points 8 months ago

Sorry I assumed the whole GCC rail was called Etihad rail. Must be only in UAE.

But it looks like people will be able to get from the GCC rail to Riyadh. Hopefully the stations are close to one another.

[–] FerNZA@lemmy.world 0 points 8 months ago

If I had to guess, the Dubai Master Plan from the 60s was probably car driven. They have to break down a lot of structures to create the metro, as well as the New Etihad Rail.

The comment about the app is more to explain the difficulties in using public transport in 50 degrees celsius if you had to wait at a bus stop.

I don’t know many rich people that take the train, so I don’t think it is specifically aimed for them. There is a first class cabin, but it is very small in my opinion.

The train does go through a lot of the richer areas yes. But I think that is mostly to get people to their places of work there.

If you are a solo traveller, the metro is a cheaper alternative to driving.

Unfortunately, here the transport card is still a must

[–] FerNZA@lemmy.world 2 points 8 months ago (2 children)

Nice video. Do you know if there is any interconnecting linking to the Etihad rail from the metro. From the news sources here it is mentioned that connection to Saudi and Oman will be connected with the UAE, but I haven't seen any more details.

[–] FerNZA@lemmy.world 1 points 8 months ago

I have only recently gone to Dubai Creek and the traffic in and out of there was really bad. I think they are targeting the highest chance of ridership first. I think the people going towards Sharjah is probably going to be the most numerous.

Personally I am more interested in the parallel line to Al Maktuom Airport, but I guess the ridership will be too little now.

[–] FerNZA@lemmy.world -1 points 8 months ago (2 children)

Everything we know so far about Dubai Metro's underground Blue Line

Sorry I stated that incorrectly, 800 meters to a public transport station. The bus picking you up to the stations does stop every few hundred meters at the different bus stops (from the parts that I have seen). There is also an app so you can follow the bus to your pick up spot so you don't have to burn in the heat waiting during summer and only exit your building once they are close. I haven't taken the RTA busses, but it works with the same card as the train, but I can't say how good it is.

Also remember the London underground has more than a hundred years on this Metro system. It doesn't cover nearly as much. I don't know how much the RTA busses cover. I have never needed to go to the parts that the Metro doesn't cover.

[–] FerNZA@lemmy.world -1 points 8 months ago* (last edited 8 months ago)

No worries.

From the link you posted, what they did to address those concerns:

In November 2020, the United Arab Emirates overhauled its legal system to loosen restrictions on alcohol consumption, permit cohabitation, and increase penalty for honor killings, among other changes

Not that I think that those things were the big changes, but the headline articles about what we find strange (in the western parts of the world) hasn't been there, except for the guy who got his fine upgraded to jail time for the incident with airport staff.

[–] FerNZA@lemmy.world 2 points 8 months ago

Okay, fair enough I guess.

[–] FerNZA@lemmy.world 5 points 8 months ago (2 children)

You do know the UAE is a different country than Qatar?

[–] FerNZA@lemmy.world 3 points 8 months ago (5 children)

Uhm, I stay here and I want the public transport to get better, which it is. Except for my work, I can reach most of my points of interests already without a car.

There is a proper sewer system. I think you are probably referring to the Burj Khalifa's first 2 months when they had problems connecting it to the sewerage system, but that has already been done. There were other hiccups and needed to have a part of it upgraded, but it was connected to the sewerage system very closely after the opening.

Some of the buildings are inspired by buildings in America, but there are influences from all around the world.

48
submitted 8 months ago* (last edited 8 months ago) by FerNZA@lemmy.world to c/fuckcars@lemmy.world
 

Looks like they plan to have the blue line extension ready to go in 2029 mentioned in the embedded video not the article.

The plan is to have 55% of the population within 800 meters of public transportation stations by 2040.

Blue line extension

A little bit old, but I always like to watch the video linked below: Youtube - Dubai Progress by MetroCucumber

[–] FerNZA@lemmy.world 12 points 9 months ago

It is fine that you don’t like it. I don’t really think you will get downvoted for it. I also don’t like LD as much as other people but I think it is fine.

There are many other trek things that I don’t like as much as other people, but in the end there are different parts of ST that resonates with different people.

The thing I like about ST is how realistic somethings from back in the day are. I also like the more serious tone of things, but I think with the popularity of things like the Orville etc you can see that a big part of the fandom was looking for something more light hearted.

Just tell your co-worker that LD is just not for you. I am sure he will understand.

[–] FerNZA@lemmy.world 13 points 10 months ago

The video isn't your cost per mile. It is the cost per mile on society as a whole per mode of transport

14
submitted 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago) by FerNZA@lemmy.world to c/fuckcars@lemmy.world
 

I recently did the jump from Reddit to Lemmy and I found this community here while I was still looking for subjects to follow. I have been following rail specific subjects (more the construction and operation of) in the few countries that I have lived in since about 2004 so some of the posts here really drew me in.

Since moving to Dubai, I wanted to go carless but my work is too remote so I did opt to get a car. I also like travelling by train so I just thought I would give an anecdotal case study of the difference between driving and taking the metro here. I also thought this would be quite interesting as the Metro system is quite young and the roads in the UAE is generally the best I have seen from Europe/North America/Africa and the Middle East (of course, I didn't see all of the roads).

Last weekend I found myself parked walking distance from Al Furjan Metro station and wanted to go close to the Metro station in JBR. This immediately made me think which option would be quicker and I checked the train schedule and it said the ride would take 11 mins and the train is running every 3 and a half minutes - 15 minutes worse case scenario including the bit of walking. I took the car and parked and walked and it took me 12 minutes to get to my destination, which would be the same as the best case scenario. The train stops at 4 stations in between, which is probably what makes this comparable.

This made me consider the other variables as well. So I decided to compare the cost. Just taking the fuel in account the trip would have cost me $0.6 for the trip in the car and this would be $3.27 for two people in the train (gold class). But I figured that isn't a very fair comparison. Lucklily I have a detailed log of my car fuel expenditure and I also log the depreciation and other expenses on my car. My car is not the cheapest one in the world, but I am also comparing it to the highest class ticket so I am just comparing it from the type of car I would want to drive and type of service I would want for the train. Adding in what my roadtrip app calculates my total cost per km. The car trip would be $2.80.

So for this trip the car came in a little bit cheaper than the gold class tickets. But if it was a solo trip it would be significantly cheaper to just take the train ($1.64). Also you could opt for the normal ticket that is $0.82 for this trip.

If you need to walk around outside the walkways, the Metro also has a nice feeder bus and tram system that is drops you 50-100 meters (55 - 110 yards) away from most points that I would be interested in.

So in conclusion, if I travel solo in Dubai, the Metro would definitely be my first choice. The ticket for two is also worth it for me as it just reduces the stress by that much.

Edit: I should probably also mention that this would probably be a harsh comparison on public transport as fuel is very cheap here and there is no tax on cars (or almost nothing if there is something)

view more: next ›