Steve Tasker from the Bills - probably the best special teams player of all time and was not a kicker
Wiki: spent 13 seasons in the NFL from 1985 to 1997, with 12 of them in Buffalo. He was a five-team first-team All-Pro and was selected to seven Pro Bowls as a special teamer. Tasker is regarded as one of the best special teamers of all time.
Bo Jackson would have been really cool to watch have a full career.