Considering what CJ Stroud has been doing, I’m interested in seeing how teams handle drafting a QB high from here on out. Over the last 20 years or so, I think we’ve seen less and less patience when it comes to rookie QBs. There used to be a time where a guy could get drafted and would essentially be a clipboard holder his first 2-3 years if the guy ahead of him was producing at at least a Cincy Andy Dalton level. We’ve seen a lot more get thrown out to the fire early and they get a lot less leeway now than they did when I first started watching football 20 something years ago.
Still tho, a lot of fans still like to justify why their teams young QB is underperforming and usually point to factors that are out of their control (roster, coaching staff, front office, lack of experience)
And this guy CJ Stroud comes into the league with a franchise in perhaps its darkest days with a rookie head coach to boot, no notable weapons at the start of the season and he’s got them in the playoff hunt and hasn’t only been playing well for a rookie but he has been one of the best performing QBs in the league this season.
I’m already seeing a lot of rumblings on social media in regards to other young QBs that have yet to play like CJ has and some guys that had supporters before this season have lost a lot of them. It’s just hard to keep justifying poor play with external excuses when this guy isn’t in an ideal situation at all and making it happen.
I’ll make a counterpoint for the sake of discussion - why shouldn’t more teams try what the Cardinals did with Rosen then Murray? I get the contract of two top 15 first round picks but probably still a bargain compared to a Burrow-Herbert or even 1-years Cousins contract.
I get wanted to prove development but what if rookie first round QB year 2 (e.g., Murray) hits (compared to 2 year QB first round year 1 (Rosen))
Sure, you’re wasting getting a first round good edge, WR, CB or OT but what if the QB gamble hits - makes year 1 step up their game or year 2 outcompete year 1
Again, just a counterpoint why not discussion based on n=1 Arizona situation.