Watches

I recently lost my Cartier Santos. My insurance has paid out a £7500 gift card. What watch should I use to buy with it?

I own an Milgauss, Omega speed master racing and a Rolex Cellini dual time. I’ve never been a big fan of dive watches as I’m a dreadful swimmer. I don’t want to buy another santos (maybe a dumont?).

Maybe something on rubber?