this post was submitted on 21 Oct 2023
1 points (100.0% liked)
Main
139 readers
3 users here now
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
My opinion on this:
Completely deserved penalty, clear foul in the box.
As for the red, I believe it’s harsh, but not unreasonable. In the replay, to me, the goalkeeper makes his mistake and then tracks the ball the whole way, ultimately fouling Morata as it falls and he pokes it away. In my opinion, he attempts to play the ball and it should be a yellow, but I understand why it was given as playing the man and deserving of a red.
I honestly don't see how it could be a red, I don't see the intentionality or the danger, and feels like an additional punishment to the penalty, which is as clear as can be.
He denied Morata a clear goal scoring opportunity. Kinda like expulsing a defender for making a last man tackle even if the foul itself is soft.
But he did that by accident, he doesn't even see Morata until he's already dropping for the ball. A pen and a yellow should be enough punishment.
The only way it’s red is if the referee believes the keeper deliberately plays Morata instead of the ball.
I’m surprised he didn’t consult the VAR monitor in the end, but it was ultimately his interpretation of the play and they weren’t about to question it due to it not being clear/obvious.
The keeper doesn't even see Morata, though. His line of sight is blocked by his own teammate and he is only looking at the ball. Morata caught him by surprise.
I don't know if they're allowed to do this, but I think that if you're going to deal such a harsh punishment you should always check the monitor just in case, on your own volition.
To be honest I think if he went to the VAR it would have solidified the decision even more. The shove comes after he makes the save and the ball gets away. Is there malice there? Not at all. But is it red card worthy? Looks an awful lot like it.
The way I interpreted it (wrong or not) was that the keeper made the save and error, then attempted to play the ball and it was poked away during the effort to retrieve it, causing contact with only Morata and not both.