this post was submitted on 20 Nov 2023
1 points (100.0% liked)

Side Project

29 readers
1 users here now

A community for sharing and receiving constructive feedback on side projects.

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
 

I got 12,000 unique visitors on UneeBee's website over the past 2 days even having only 200 followers on social media. I'd like to share what worked and what didn't work. Hopefully, some of this will be helpful to other people launching products in the future.

What worked

Hacker News

It's the main responsible for the launch success. I got 400+ upvotes, 100+ comments and made to the front page, staying there the whole day on Saturday.

Most posts I see on the Show HN section are just a link to the landing page. I want to make it more personal. I also wrote a short text explaining what I was building and why I was building it. Plus, I asked for honest feedback and the community helped a lot.

I posted it on Saturday around 1 am PST. I think this helped a little bit. Lots of people were online checking out the OpenAI drama and we didn't have many posts because it was a Friday night after all. I think all that helped to catch people's attention.

Reddit

I posted on three communities: r/opensource, r/SideProject and r/ProductHunters.

The OpenSource community had the best result by far: 10.9k views, 64 upvotes, 20 comments, 8 shares and the discussion there was so good it actually changed my mind about UneeBee's license, which is now AGPL.

The SideProject folks were also nice. I got 2.6k views there, 11 upvotes, 8 comments, and 16 shares. However, my post on the ProductHunters subreddit didn't work. It got only 75 views and 2 upvotes.

On the OpenSource subreddit, I focused more on why I'm building this project. On the SideProject one, I used the same post I published on Hacker News. But, on Product Hunters, I only shared a link to the Product Hunt page because that's what the rules allow there. Clearly telling a story is more impactful than just sharing a link.

What didn't work

Product Hunt

I only got 14 upvotes on Product Hunt and it didn't get featured on the home page. It was a total failure.

I followed their recommendation and launched it one minute past midnight on Pacific Time. I linked to the Product Hunt page on all my communications (Hacker News, Reddit, social media). No luck. Maybe I did something wrong but I got the feeling Product Hunt only works if you have a good social media presence, which isn't my case.

I'll try again in the future but I'll probably won't spend much time on it.

Social media

I posted on X, Threads, LinkedIn, Instagram, and Facebook. Both on my personal profile and on Zoonk's. I got some minor engagement on X and LinkedIn but everything else flopped.

As I said, I don't have a big social media presence. So, tbh, I wasn't expecting great results there. My hope was that a big account would eventually like UneeBee after seeing it somewhere else and repost it, driving engagement up but that didn't help. I know I need to improve my social media presence but, tbh, right now I prefer to focus most of my energy on making UneeBee better.

Indie Hackers

I had some success with Indie Hackers in the past but it didn't work this time. My post got only 21 views, no comments nor likes. I used the same post that worked on Hacker News. I think, overall, Indie Hackers has potential if you manage to be active on the community, which (ironically) is hard when you're an indie hacker and have limited time.

Conclusion

Hacker News worked much better than I expected but I feel it was a little bit of luck. I don't if it's going to work in the future again. Reddit also seems a good place to be, especially to get some feedback on what you're doing. I'll try to be more active there.

Product Hunt doesn't feel very useful unless you have a big social media presence. Increasing social media presence requires a lot of work, though. I'm not sure how to do it while keep improving the product, which is my main priority right now.

top 10 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] rockntalk@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Hey congrats on the success of your product.

And don’t feel bad about Product Hunt failure, it just depends on the product and timing.

My product, again related to open-source tools received more than 5 times traffic in a few hours on from Hacker News compared to the whole day on Product Hunt. Of course, HN is a fire - shouldn’t get depressed seeing some comments ;)

Also, feel free to submit your product on Open Source Stash - this is the product I am referring to.

[–] doobsicle@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Did you make a normal HN post or was it a Show HN post? I find ShowHN is pretty sleepy. Another helpful aspect is that your product is open source, which I feel like is always a crowd-pleaser over at HN.

[–] corporat@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

I'm surprised you liked the response of /r/opensource. They did the classic thing for that subreddit of focusing on your license (which idk imo it's irrelevant*) and bringing up alternatives that no one uses or cares about.

* VCs who invest in open source really prefer Apache. If you think you want to take investments, maybe don't release with a license yet, or close PRs until you get some advice on that subject

[–] Riviera20@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Great post! Thanks for sharing

[–] pentaclay@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Great news. Glad you got some traction.

I do run a DaaS (Design as a Subscription) business. I launched on several platforms like HackerNews, Indie Hackers, Reddit, X, Facebook, and LinkedIn.

I also don't have many followers on social media. But I got a hit post on Reddit.

I posted a couple of articles on multiple subreddits. Out of them, r/SideProject worked really well. The post got 17k+ views and counting.

I got almost 500+ visitors from that post, but not any conversion yet.

I will give another try to HackerNews.

[–] collins30@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

As a digital marketer, I can easily understand why social media didn't work for you. Unlike the other platforms you mentioned, SM needs some level of "romancing"

What I do for client's is to start by telling their story even before launch so the momentum builds. Then after launch, I still post consistently in a way that attracts the right audience - mainly TOFU kind of content

[–] MrBubble4u@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Loved the breakdown! Tyvm for sharing :)

[–] zipItKaren@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

!remindme in 3 days

[–] zipItKaren@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

!remindme in 3 days

[–] ZippyTyro@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

awesome, reddit always works if you've good stuff to show. slowly build a following on X, as it's also worth it, later on through it you can get more traction on ProductHunt.