I’d like them to give it to a defensive player if they’re not gonna give it to a QB. CMC and Tyreek are amazing and both having great years but the quarterback is by far the most valuable position for an offense and it clearly shows when Purdy or Tua have off games. They put up their numbers but the QB is what wins or losses you games on the offensive side.
Defense on the other hand can definitely win you games even with a struggling offense. Garret would be a great choice since that defense is carrying the browns hard. TJ Watt is another option for the same reason.
How would Tyreek be more valuable than the guy throwing him the ball and running the entire offense? Same with CMC. There’s a reason why Tua and Purdy are ahead of them in the odds right now. Without great QB play the position players don’t really matter.