You've gotten great types on a system to manage the ratings, but I'll point out that the way you assign them can be important. I like the process where you go through different stages of binary choices, starting out extremely fast and whittling the numbers down eventually going slower with a smaller set. All similar variations: 1 2 3
Others like to go through photos once and choose between 1-5.
I'll just add there are great small modern lenses, e.g. Samyang's tiny lenses for Sony full frame. Not pictured is the 24/1.8 which is a similar size yet similar quality to the Sony GM 24/1.4, other than the aperture, though not all of them are quite to that level optically.