this post was submitted on 09 Mar 2026
659 points (85.7% liked)
Memes
54917 readers
679 users here now
Rules:
- Be civil and nice.
- Try not to excessively repost, as a rule of thumb, wait at least 2 months to do it if you have to.
founded 6 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Both are bad???
Yeah, and the Big Bad Wolf is bad, but it's also a western fairy tale.
Pretty sure social credit actually exists tho. No? It's a fairy tale? smh.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_credit_system
That article is actually a pretty great source on it being a fairy tale. What's your disagreement? And if you disagree with the Wikipedia article, why are you linking it with no commentary?
Did this meme argue that social credit score doesn't exist? Or is it whataboutism that argues that you can't criticize the social credit system (real or not) because America has a credit score system. My point is, you can be against BOTH. That is all I'm saying here
No, you can't criticize the Chinese social credit score, because it doesn't exist.
And it's not "whataboutism" to tell westerners to stop trying to "fix" other countries while living in a world ruled by pedophile billionaires and pretending they have "freedom".
Your "solution" to everything is to invade, kill a bunch of innocent people, and install a worse, unelected government. So stop trying to analyze problems with other countries, real or fake. (In this case very fake)
When did I mention invading places? Apparently I'm the embodiment of America itself? God I wish because all I'd have to do is kill myself
No, you are a part of something much bigger than yourself. Again, I'm addressing you as a western liberal. If any part of that is wrong, feel free to correct me. But if you are using the term "whataboutism" and crying about policies in China that you have admitted you have no idea about, then you are pushing western liberal ideals, and are a part of the same problem. Also, I did not mention America at all. If you think what I'm talking about is limited to America, I don't know. You need to read more.
I mean, if anything I'm going to become a political descendant in the west if things keep up so I'm by no means trying to be a propaganda machine for the west, if I came off that way I apologize. However, I assumed you meant America specifically though because you mentioned "pedophile billionaires" which would imply that I'm a MAGA Chud that backs up or at least turns a blind eye to pedophilia as they are right now. I imagine most people in the EU, Canada, etc aren't doing that, but maybe I'm wrong. Anyway, at least we both agree that America bad
The criticism is that westerners believe in something that both doesn't exist (the popular "social credit" myth) and also is much closer to existing where they live.
one of them doesn't even fucking exist
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_credit_system
citing the natopedia article as if it's an actual source lol
i've lived in china; i don't need to edit shit.
They didn't even read the first section of the article they linked.
Sure, let's say it doesn't since I admittedly haven't looked into this in painful detail. However, this meme seems to suggest that if it did exist, then it would be perfectly fine on the virtue that credit scores exist in America. Aka, whataboutism.
Since Germany made concentration camps under the third reich that it isn't that bad when America does it. At least by this logic. Guess it's impossible to be against two things at once. Though I hope I'm just misinterpreting the point
You can stop right there and try shutting the fuck up then until you do lmao
You didn't read the rest of the comment since I conceded that it doesn't exist for that reason and why I still disagree with the meme
And you haven't read anything about China's so-called social credit system yet here you are engaging in debate perversion.
The meme is pointing out hypocrisy among those in America. Its common to hear them mock China for having a social credit score system, while apparently not realizing they have exactly that with credit monitoring companies.
This is all made more ridiculous by the fact that there is no social credit score in China as Americans understand it.
The joke is that Americans brag and call everyone else barbarians, when they themselves are the barbarians. Its pure projection to inflate the massive American ego.
That's not what "whataboutism" is. This isn't a structured debate where we are limited to one topic, it's a conversation... and we're allowed to use examples and compare like to like, you do it, I do it, every human on Earth does it every day.
Sure, you're allowed to call this and everything else 'whataboutism', I don't think you should be given a "whataboutism score" wherein those with the highest scores are avoided by reasonable people.
I await your charge of gaslighting eagerly
Exactly my thoughts. People just mass downvote into oblivion, no reasoning provided.
Reasoning has been provided all over this thread, including by users from instances you cannot see because Lemmy.world censored them from your view.
Where do you get your news from? Not going to continue to argue, but I'm just curious
No one place, I see the same mainstream western news as everyone, I just also read articles from outside the west as well, and non-mainstream sources too.
Yeah, I just wonder which sources are "from outside the west" since I'm trying my best to break my echo chamber
CGTN is pretty mainstream for news from China, they have English news. The Cradle is typically decent on reporting from the Middle East. For western and glonal news from a communist angle, BreakThrough News and Geopolitical Economy Report are both good.