this post was submitted on 18 Nov 2023
1 points (100.0% liked)
Ethereum
5 readers
1 users here now
Resources
- Website & Blog
- White Paper & Yellow Paper
- Documentation & Stack Exchange
- Learn Solidity
- Source Code on Github
- Bounty program
- Chat on Gitter
- Network Status & Gas Price Market
- List of DApps
- Meetups
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
You're forgetting that the cost of storing data has always decreased. By having the revolutionary upfront price for data storage, it's a huge bet on this trend.
The price of ETH goes to the moon. ETH price is determined not only by speculation but also by actual demand to pay to put data on chain. If it becomes commonplace to store data on chain, it will greatly increase demand for ETH.
I've made https://clonk.me to have conversations and share files on chain as NFTs and https://newgeocities.com to upload web pages on chain.
It doesn't matter if Eth price goes to the moon, the economic model is fundamentally flawed.
> Users start dumping data on-chain that must remain forever
> Eth price goes to the moon
Where in this equation are nodes being compensated for storing data? The fees that users pay to *add* data do not count -- that's a completely different cost than storing data. The nodes that join any time in the future are burdened **without payment** for all data that came before - the payment went to the nodes that added it and, apparently, Eth holders, if your solutions is 'Eth price goes to moon.'
If your argument is that people won't be able to add such data because it's too expensive -- just mete it out. Add it during low demand. It really doesn't matter; nodes get paid to *add* data, nobody gets paid to *keep* data; at least they aren't paid anything like a market rate. The solution now is just let fees increase to compensate the node cost, meaning new users pay for old uers - a truly awful economic model.
Anticipating the next argument: "the chain will just stay small enough so that storage costs decrease more quickly than archive costs." You are now a slightly better version of small-block Bitcoin (same economic model: don't allow arbitrary scaling) i.e. you have economic parameters set by developers and not the free market.
Automatic Transaction Rebroadcasting solves it. It gives you market prices for storage and pays that money to nodes actually storing it.