this post was submitted on 26 Oct 2023
1 points (100.0% liked)

NFL

77 readers
1 users here now

A place for NFL news, game highlights and everything that excites you about American Football.

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
 

Let’s hear it! Give me your most unpopular opinions so far this season. I know this sub can be a hive mind echo chamber sometimes where people all arrive at certain assumptions and conclusions based on small sample sizes or bias’.

Here’s a few of my unpopular (to this sub) takes:

  1. RBs aren’t a “luxury” pick in the first round of the draft, you just have to accept that the pick won’t be as “long term” as other positions. Drafting guys like CMC, Travis ETN, Bijan, etc. aren’t “wastes” or “luxuries”. Those guys can really aid an offense, especially in the current era where we’re coming back around to ground attacks. The big issue is the second contract, but you’ll still have a stud weapon on the cheap for 4-5 years. More specially, I don’t see anything wrong with the Gibbs pick. People think he’s a bust or a waste bc he hasn’t been a 20-25 touch guy 6 games into his career… I think he can be a huge contributor for them for 4 seasons or so. If he helps them in big playoff games, then the pick is worth it, even if he’s not a guy who’s around for 6-10 seasons.

  2. A QBs ability to process info and remained poised is far more important than athletic ability. Everyone is looking for the shiny athlete like Josh Allen or Lamar, but honestly guys like Brock Purdy, Kirk, Goff, etc. are way more attainable and way safer. They can process info and deliver accurate passes. Obviously the gold standard is a freak athlete who’s an elite processor, but I think some teams try to find the athletes first then try to teach the mental aspect. While it’s true that you can’t teach athletic ability like Fields has, or the arm talent Wilson has, it’s not so easy to teach the mental component either.

What’re your guys’ hot takes and unpopular opinions?

(page 6) 45 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] TJeffersonsBlackKid@alien.top 1 points 1 year ago

The Saints have no one to blame but themselves in the “rigged” NFC championship game.

If they just ran the ball on the next two downs, they would have pretty much guaranteed a win.

Also, 49ers fans are the biggest crybabies in sports.

I think this is going to be super unpopular, but I’m fed up with Kyle Shanahan and the 49ers. I know injuries have played a major role in them not winning a championship but he choked the 28-3 lead as the offensive coordinator of the falcons and also blew a ten point lead in the Super Bowl. In his time as coach, some stellar coaches have won the Super Bowl (Reid, McVay, Arians) but we keep treating Shanahan like he’s one of those guys. If he can’t beat Philly in the nfc playoffs this year, who’s to say Siriani isn’t a better coach? What if they lose to the Lions or a different random nfc team in the playoffs? What excuse will it be this time.

Just win a Super Bowl man. I’m tired of hearing how smart you are when you have zero championships. The same narrative surrounded McVay, but then he won a Super Bowl.

The Niners to me are like the Boston Celtics. Everyone knows they’re really good, they’ve been one of the best teams in the league for the last 10 years. They also have zero championships. I’m tired of hearing how good Jayson Tatum and Jaylen Brown are. Just win man. Even the Raptors won a chip in that time frame, just like one of the WORST franchises in nfl history won one (Bucs 2020) during Shanahans tenure.

There are only 2 QBs who are sure fire HOFs in the nfl rn: Rodgers and Mahomes.

Maybe you can say Wilson and Stafford.

But get the hell outta here with this weird Kirk Cousins to the hall of fame crap. No HOF QB has ever checked it down for a 4 yard gain with the SEASON on the line (talking about last years playoff game vs NY). Kirk has been a very average QB his whole career and has one stinking playoff win. Joe Burrow, Lamar Jackson and Josh Allen have all already had better careers than Kirk Cousins. I will fight people over this— he’s a very average QB who needs EVERYTHING to go right in order to win.

[–] matmortel@alien.top 1 points 1 year ago

I think the league is too qb driven. If they implement the rules that help out the defense a but more, the "meta" could change. Of course good qbs have always been essential, but we won't ever see a team like the 2000s ravens or the 85 bears ever again. Defenses can't be that dominant anymore because of the rules.

[–] ToodleDoodleDo@alien.top 1 points 1 year ago

The Browns aren't the only team that knowingly employ bad people

[–] Viking141@alien.top 1 points 1 year ago

Forward pass is a trick play.

[–] ComplainAboutLeague@alien.top 1 points 1 year ago

That Tony Romo was never the problem in Dallas. He was underrated through his career, and conservative play calling from the Dallas OCs over his career cost him the chance of being in the HOF. There were large stretches of his career where he would put up the same/better numbers than Rodgers, but because the Cowboys never had it together coaching wise, they were never really a superbowl threat in his prime.

What could have been had he ended up at a real franchise.

[–] iNSANEwOw@alien.top 1 points 1 year ago

Skill positions are vastly overrated, an elite OLine and pass rush gets you wins regardless of a potentially mediocre QB or supporting cast. If your OLine is good then you will have plenty of time to throw and your rungame is scary even with some 6th round RB. On the other hand if your OLine sucks then it doesnt matter if you have Mahomes and Kelce, they cant do shit just like in Superbowl LV.

[–] RukiMotomiya@alien.top 1 points 1 year ago

QB is the most important position in football, but it's overall importance is overstated. Many teams in the last decade or so have made deep runs or won Super Bowls with merely "good" QBs and they will continue to do so in the future. People act like QB is Everything or that nobody else can be the most valuable just because of the QB position and I disagree with that level.

Similarly, Cooper Kupp should have won MVP or at least been legitimately in the conversation in 2021. Stafford is IMO an underrated QB for most of his career, but in no way does he lead them to a Super Bowl without Kupp's all-time great play. Kupp is why they beat the Brady Bucs to advance and he helped keep the team on track when Woods went down and OBJ was just okay during the regular season. People discount a season like this simply for not playing QB, but with and without Kupp was also a huge difference. Hell the year before they won their playoff game w/ Goff and Kupp, then lost the one he got injured for a very simplistic look. Barely even being considered is a joke.

[–] CaseACEjk@alien.top 1 points 1 year ago (1 children)

I have no idea how anybody can even remotely think eli manning is a hall of famer.

I have a screenshot of all his career numbers that shuts people down right away but still baffles me how little fb knowledge people have or the intent of the hof.

[–] Legitimate-Map-5351@alien.top 1 points 1 year ago

The thing that staggers me looking back at his numbers is the number of interceptions he threw. Mind boggling really

[–] donrhummy@alien.top 1 points 1 year ago

That people don't really want real performance enhancing drug testing. If the NFL players were truly drug free, there would be half as many fans

[–] dcviapa@alien.top 1 points 1 year ago

They should put the kicking PAT line of scrimmage where it used to be but not allow kicking specialists to do it. I wanna see giant men kick straight on again, damn it!

[–] Nickyq52@alien.top 1 points 1 year ago

Devin Hester is not a hall of famer

[–] boomheadshot7@alien.top 1 points 1 year ago

One day contracts are stupid.

Fans saying "we", "us", etc. when talking about thier favorite team is cringy.

[–] its_JustColin@alien.top 1 points 1 year ago

I’m the exact opposite of you on QBs. When you have a superstar QB like Allen, Jackson or Mahomes a high completion percentage doesn’t matter at all. I prefer the years where Allen’s completion percentage is in the 60s compared to this year where it’s in the 70s but our offense keeps stalling

Jackson is a little different

[–] AnEngineer2018@alien.top 1 points 1 year ago

QB stat padding is a thing and so many media personalities in the MVP discussions just ignore it. Like wow so cool, they threw for 500 yards, no interceptions, 2 TDs and the final score was 17 to 15.

Kick the damn field goals

[–] ATX_rider@alien.top 1 points 1 year ago

The QB position has far too much weight on it. Get it right a couple of times in a row like the Packers did and you have a three decade run. Ridiculous. MaHomey shouldn't make the Chiefs a contender for 20 years but sadly he will.

Makes the game pretty boring.

[–] Agentwise@alien.top 1 points 1 year ago

Dez didn’t catch it. Just because a rule was changed later doesn’t retroactively apply those rules to previous plays. He didn’t catch it by the rules of the game at the time and therefore didn’t catch it.

[–] Tjam3s@alien.top 1 points 1 year ago

It's not as hard as people think to get refs to fix a game. It doesn't have to be a conspiracy any bigger than the league and a relative handful of part-time employees.

They get compensated by gambling, and everyone stays quiet.

[–] MixIllustrious861@alien.top 1 points 1 year ago

No decent parent would let their child play football.

load more comments
view more: ‹ prev next ›