this post was submitted on 23 Nov 2023
1 points (100.0% liked)

NBA - Main

14 readers
1 users here now

Game analysis, highlights and everything else that is happening in the NBA.

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
 

As some of you may know, every night, I've been recapping the performances of rookies with significant playing time every night. In doing so, I have collected a pretty good amount of data in regard to how these rookies have been playing so far this season. Below, I have compiled some of the data that may or may not mean anything to you. Remember that the data doesn't really show how good a rookie has been, unless that data shows that the rookie on your team is good. Then it's perfectly fine.

Naturally, the most apparent metric to show if you've been following the daily posts is the number of crowns and the number of snowflakes each player has been awarded. If you haven't been following, the crown is given to whoever had the best performance that night, and the snowflake is "awarded" to the player who had the worst. These performances are always sorted by Game Score, an advanced stat that puts one number on an entire performance. Here is the definition of game score, ripped straight off of Basketball Reference:

The formula is PTS + 0.4 * FG - 0.7 * FGA - 0.4*(FTA - FT) + 0.7 * ORB + 0.3 * DRB + STL + 0.7 * AST + 0.7 * BLK - 0.4 * PF - TOV. Game Score was created by John Hollinger to give a rough measure of a player's productivity for a single game. The scale is similar to that of points scored, (40 is an outstanding performance, 10 is an average performance, etc.).

With that said, here is a table of rookies sorted by number of crowns:

# ๐Ÿ‘‘ Player (Team)
5 Victor Wembanyama (SAS)
4 Chet Holmgren (OKC)
3 Dereck Lively II (DAL)
2 Bilal Coulibaly (WAS)
2 Craig Porter Jr (CLE)
2 Jaime Jaquez Jr (MIA)
2 Ausar Thompson (DET)
1 Brandin Podziemski (GSW)
1 Marcus Sasser (DET)
1 Jordan Hawkins (NOP)
1 Anthony Black (ORL)
1 Brandon Miller (CHO)

And here is the table for the number of snowflakes:

โ€‹

# โ„๏ธ Player (Team)
3 Gradey Dick (TOR)
3 Andre Jackson Jr (MIL)
2 Scoot Henderson (POR)
2 Dereck Lively II (DAL)
2 Sasha Vezenkov (SAC)
2 Duop Reath (POR)
1 Cam Whitmore (HOU)
1 Bilal Coulibaly (WAS)
1 Craig Porter Jr (CLE)
1 Toumani Camara (POR)
1 Colby Jones (SAC)
1 Brandon Miller (CHO)
1 D'Moi Hodge (LAL)
1 Colin Gillespie (DEN)
1 Anthony Black (ORL)
1 Cason Wallace (OKC)
1 Vasilije Micic (OKC)
1 Jaime Jaquez Jr (MIA)
1 Julian Strawther (DEN)

While this data is somewhat interesting to look at, it doesn't really mean a whole lot. Generally, the better rookies will have more crowns and the worse ones will have more snowflakes, but if a player has a great performance that gets one-upped by another player the same night, they get no credit for that here.

Another issue with this is that it doesn't take into account the number of rookies who actually played that day. Getting a crown on a full slate where 17 rookies played is a lot more impressive than getting one on a day with four games and four rookies played.

To counteract these issues, I've ranked every rookie in a new stat that I created called Ahead Minus Behind (AMB). This stat takes a rookie's performance and adds 1 for every rookie the first rookie outperformed that night and subtracts 1 for every rookie that outperformed them (all by Game Score).

Here is the table for AMB with the highest at the top:

Rank Pick: Rookie (Team) Ahead Minus Behind (AMB)
1 2022 Pick 2: Chet Holmgren (OKC) 120
2 Pick 5: Ausar Thompson (DET) 84
3 Pick 1: Victor Wembanyama (SAS) 73
4 Pick 2: Brandon Miller (CHO) 50
5 Pick 12: Dereck Lively II (DAL) 46
6 Undrafted: Craig Porter Jr (CLE) 23
7 Pick 14: Jordan Hawkins (NOP) 21
8 Pick 18: Jaime Jaquez Jr (MIA) 18
9 Pick 25: Marcus Sasser (DET) 14
10 Pick 10: Cason Wallace (OKC) 9
11 Pick 8: Jarace Walker (IND) 8
12 Pick 23: Kris Murray (POR) 7
T-13 Pick 19: Brandin Podziemski (GSW) 1
T-13 Pick 32: Jalen Pickett (DEN) 1
T-15 Pick 16: Keyonte George (UTA) -1
T-15 Pick 49: Emoni Bates (CLE) -1
17 Pick 54: Jalen Slawson (SAC) -3
T-18 Pick 57: Trayce Jackson-Davis (GSW) -5
T-18 Pick 34: Colby Jones (SAC) -5
T-18 Pick 26: Ben Sheppard (IND) -5
T-18 Pick 30: Kobe Brown (LAC) -5
T-22 Pick 27: Nick Smith Jr (CHO) -7
T-22 Undrafted: Jermaine Samuels (HOU) -7
24 Pick 7: Bilal Coulibaly (WAS) -9
T-25 Pick 43: Rayan Rupert (POR) -11
T-25 Undrafted: Colin Castleton (LAL) -11
27 Pick 29: Julian Strawther (DEN) -12
28 Undrafted: D'Moi Hodge (LAL) -13
T-29 2014 Pick 52: Vasilije Micic (OKC) -16
T-29 Pick 36: Andre Jackson Jr (MIL) -16
31 Pick 20: Cam Whitmore (HOU) -19
32 Pick 3: Scoot Henderson (POR) -21
33 Pick 4: Amen Thompson (HOU) -29
34 Undrafted: Collin Gillespie (DEN) -31
35 2017 Pick 57: Sasha Vezenkov (SAC) -35
36 Pick 6: Anthony Black (ORL) -42
37 Undrafted: Duop Reath (POR) -43
38 Pick 13: Gradey Dick (TOR) -46
39 Pick 52: Toumani Camara (POR) -49

โ€‹

Now, one problem with this is that it doesn't take playing time into account. For instance, Jarace Walker is pretty high on this table, but his sample space is only 2 games in where he played 10+ minutes.

Here is a chart with the x-axis showing minutes played and the y-axis showing AMB:

https://imgur.com/a/Vos4NGe

And for fun, here is the same chart but the x-axis is draft pick:

https://imgur.com/RddBsvX

Using this trendline, we can come up with the so called "steals of the draft" based on how far above the line they are.

If we avoid looking at the first 5 draft picks the biggest "steals" are Craig Porter Jr, Dereck Lively II, and Jaime Jaquez Jr in that order.

We can do the same for the "biggest busts" one month into these players' careers.

Avoiding the second round, we can determine that the biggest "busts" so far have been Gradey Dick, Anthony Black, and Bilal Coulibaly in that order. Technically Amen Thompson and Scoot Henderson are farther below the line than Coulibaly, however, early injuries to both have made their rankings impossible to actually use in this way.

I've also been keeping track of the leaders of each stat every day. In the daily posts, I've been italicizing the number of each stat that was the highest.

Here are all of the rookies that led the night in scoring more than once:

Times Led (Points) Player
5 Chet Holmgren
5 Victor Wembanyama
3 Jordan Hawkins
2 Craig Porter Jr
2 Jaime Jaquez Jr
2 Dereck Lively II
2 Marcus Sasser

Here is the same for rebounds:

Times Led (Rebounds) Player
8 Ausar Thompson
5 Victor Wembanyama
4 Chet Holmgren
4 Dereck Lively II

Here is the same for assists:

Times Led (Assists) Player
8 Keyonte George
4 Scoot Henderson
3 Victor Wembanyama
3 Ausar Thompson
2 Craig Porter Jr
2 Jaime Jaquez Jr
2 Chet Holmgren
2 Vasilije Micic
2 Marcus Sasser

For steals and blocks, the numbers start to get ugly because there have been many days when four or five players led with just 1 or 2 steals/blocks. Because of this, I feel like the data isn't very useful and potentially misleading, so I'm deciding against showing that here.

Now for individual performances. Below are a few tables that go over the best performances by a rookie this season so far in each stat.

Top 10 Performances by Game Score

Game Score Player (Date) Statline
32.5 Chet Holmgren (11/18) 36/10/5 (4 OREB), 2 STL, 1 BLK, 4 TOV, 2 PF, 14/22 FG, 2/5 3P, 6/7 FT, 37 minutes
29.8 Victor Wembanyama (11/02) 38/10/2, 1 STL, 2 BLK, 2 TOV, 3 PF, 15/26 FG, 3/6 3P, 5/6 FT, 34 minutes
25.7 Chet Holmgren (11/03) 24/8/5 (3 OREB), 1 STL, 1 BLK, 2 TOV, 4 PF, 7/9 FG, 2/2 3P, 8/8 FT, 32 minutes
25.1 Jordan Hawkins (11/06) 31/7/3, 1 STL, 1 TOV, 2 PF, 10/19 FG, 7/14 3P, 4/5 FT, 38 minutes
23.0 Victor Wembanyama (11/10) 29/9/4, 1 STL, 4 BLK, 3 TOV, 5 PF, 12/21 FG, 3/7 3P, 2/4 FT, 35 minutes
22.5 Ausar Thompson (11/14) 21/7/5, 3 STL, 2 BLK, 2 TOV, 3 PF, 9/12 FG, 0/1 3P, 3/6 FT, 35 minutes
22.1 Craig Porter Jr (11/19) 21/4/4, 2 STL, 1 BLK, 1 TOV, 3 PF, 7/10 FG, 7/7 FT, 25 minutes
21.6 Brandon Miller (11/18) 29/3/2, 2 TOV, 3 PF, 10/15 FG, 5/7 3P, 4/4 FT, 34 minutes
21.0 Bilal Coulibaly (11/12) 20/7/3, 4 STL, 2 TOV, 8/12 FG, 4/7 3P, 0/1 FT, 34 minutes
20.7 Chet Holmgren (10/27) 16/13/2, 1 STL, 7 BLK, 1 TOV, 3 PF, 5/9 FG, 3/4 3P, 3/4 FT, 31 minutes

โ€‹

Here is the top ten for points:

Points Player Date
38 Victor Wembanyama 11/02
36 Chet Holmgren 11/18
31 Jordan Hawkins 11/06
29 Brandon Miller 11/18
29 Victor Wembanyama 11/10
27 Victor Wembanyama 11/17
26 Marcus Sasser 11/08
25 Jordan Hawkins 11/14
24 Chet Holmgren 11/3
23 Brandin Podziemski 11/14

โ€‹

For rebounds (Top 9, 3-way tie for 10th):

Rebounds Player Date
16 Ausar Thompson 11/12
15 Ausar Thompson 11/08
14 Dereck Lively II 11/05
14 Victor Wembanyama 11/14
13 Chet Holmgren 10/27
13 Dereck Lively II 11/1
13 Ausar Thompson 10/27
13 Ausar Thompson 11/10
13 Victor Wembanyama 11/18

โ€‹

For assists (Top 9, 7-way tie for 10th):

Assists Player Date
11 Keyonte George 11/10
11 Keyonte George 11/19
9 Keyonte George 11/08
9 Craig Porter Jr 11/21
7 Keyonte George 11/14
7 Scoot Henderson 10/30
7 Scoot Henderson 11/01
7 Vasilije Micic 11/16
7 Victor Wembanyama 11/12

โ€‹

For steals (Top 11):

Steals Player Date
4 Bilal Coulibaly 11/12
4 Marcus Sasser 11/01
4 Ausar Thompson 11/05
4 Ausar Thompson 11/06
4 Cason Wallace 11/06
3 Toumani Camara 11/08
3 Bilal Coulibaly 11/01
3 Bilal Coulibaly 11/13
3 Jaime Jaquez Jr 11/12
3 Ausar Thompson 11/14
3 Victor Wembanyama 10/27

โ€‹

For blocks (Top 9, 6-way tie for 10th):

Blocks Player Date
8 Victor Wembanyama 11/18
7 Chet Holmgren 10/27
5 Ausar Thompson 10/25
5 Victor Wembanyama 11/05
4 Chet Holmgren 10/30
4 Trayce Jackson-Davis 10/30
4 Ausar Thompson 11/05
4 Victor Wembanyama 10/31
4 Victor Wembanyama 11/10

โ€‹

For turnovers:

Turnovers Player Date
7 Victor Wembanyama 11/12
5 Keyonte George 11/19
5 Scoot Henderson 10/27
5 Chet Holmgren 11/01
5 Ausar Thompson 11/17
5 Ausar Thompson 11/19
5 Victor Wembanyama 10/25
5 Victor Wembanyama 10/29
5 Victor Wembanyama 10/31
5 Victor Wembanyama 11/14

โ€‹

And just for fun, the 5 worst performances by Game Score (at least 10 minutes):

Game Score Player (Date) Statline
-4.5 Gradey Dick (11/17) 0/1/1, 2 TOV, 0/5 FG, 0/4 3P, 10 minutes
-4.5 Duop Reath (11/14) 0/1/0, 2 TOV, 1 PF, 0/4 FG, 0/3 3P, 10 minutes
-3.5 Cam Whitmore (10/25) 0/1/0, 1 TOV, 0/4 FG, 0/2 3P, 10 minutes
-3.1 Scoot Henderson (10/27) 7/3/2, 1 STL, 5 TOV, 5 PF, 3/12 FG, 1/5 3P, 25 minutes
-3.0 Scoot Henderson (10/29) 4/1/3, 1 BLK, 4 TOV, 5 PF, 2/7 FG, 0/4 3P, 27 minutes

If you would like to know any more stats about this year's rookie class so far, please let me know. I'm more than happy to add a few more tables here if they are interesting enough.

top 10 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[โ€“] Bard_Wannabe_@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

I still can't believe Ausar is out-rebounding 7 and a half foot giants.

[โ€“] FactCheckingThings@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Dick has been playing like ass, hope he can turn it around and find his shot.

[โ€“] whoissteveo@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Wow, this is fantastic stuff.

It's way too early to make any conclusions, but Craig Porter Jr. ranking as the 6th best rookie as an undrafted player is bonkers. And he's definitely going to keep getting minutes because he's the type of player that JB loves.

[โ€“] Aggressive_Slice4620@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Just like Kyle Singler, you're the GOAT!!

[โ€“] BluejayBlend@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

this is soooo fucking sick

โ€‹

also oh my god ausar thompson

[โ€“] axnjxn00@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

AB has been good

Jett Howard is unplayable, but he doesn't make this list because of it

[โ€“] mkonich@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Cool stuff. A lot of surprising stuff, but more than anything, I wonder how many times a rookie has attempted 14 threes in a game just a month into a season! (Jordan Hawkins)

[โ€“] FlowVoids@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Victor is the most interesting to watch and Chet is the best on the best team, but man Ausar Thompson is probably the most fun to watch.

[โ€“] im_not_here_for_long@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

this is dope and i appreciate the insane amount of work that went into this but it highlights the limitations of pure stat based analysis imo. anthony black, for example, is starting and playing 20 min a game for the 3 seed magic. he's an important cog in that team even if he doesn't stuff the stat sheet at all, he's for sure not a top 3 biggest draft bust this year. similar story with coulibaly. it is just one month in tho so maybe things change, either way, thanks for sharing!

[โ€“] macroball_pod@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Really good stuff - keep up the good work!!