I'm surprised this doesn't seem to be quite as unrealistic as I thought it would be.
this post was submitted on 28 Oct 2026
38 points (100.0% liked)
CanadaPolitics
3449 readers
26 users here now
Placeholder for any r/CanadaPolitics refugees
Rules
- Keep the original title when submitting an article. You can put your own commentary in the body of the post or in the comment section.
- Has to be relevant to Canadian politics.
Reminder that the rules for lemmy.ca also apply here. See the sidebar on the homepage: lemmy.ca
founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
Yeah... ugh... no? Unless you invent a higher voltage transmission method, transferring electricity that far would be wildly inefficient. Its obviously possible, but why? It would be the most expensive electricity in the world.
Hudson Bay electricity goes as far as New York, ~1750km with 10% losses. Getting that same electricity to say France would be 5000km and the article says 30% losses.
Even Churchill Falls to Scotland is 3500km+.
If you could up the voltage though, yeah its not a bad idea but we are dealing with 2x to 3x the distances we see in Quebec.
Then what... a Russian sub can just turn the lights out in Western Europe?
With the right ‘complimentary’ technologies, this ‘power’ cable could detect subs quite effectively
Then what... a Russian sub can just turn the lights out in Western Europe?
Europe would still have their own power generation... It would just improve generation/consumption mismatches. By island hopping you could shorten the buried lengths, to make replacing damaged sections easier.
Happy valley goose bay to the tip of Greenland, up the coast to kulusuk, across to Iceland, then to faroe islands then maybe Shetland, Bergen, Stavanger etc.
Seems like the sort of thing that isn't unreasonable to study.
It’s hard to imagine that it wouldn’t be cheaper and more reliable to do a massive solar project in Northern Africa.
That's probably also a good idea.
this is why you dont publish the other 6 communication projects.
Apparently they power it from both ends. So the distance to maximum loss will be the halfway point. So very roughly about 16% loss from either end based on the HBE numbers you provided.
Upping the voltage has limits because you're actually powering repeaters along the cable.
edit: Oop my bad. I thought this was about the proposed data cable. Not power.
they need like a spider web that has no single weak point
A spider still weaves its web one strand at a time...
LNG
Maybe we don't try to sell MORE fracking dinosaur farts?
But let's get a cable to a substation on Hans Island, and let the greenlanders figure their side.
That feels like a draft of academic paper written before they found the sources to put in and pad it out a bit.
I like the idea but the discussion or method section does not talk about how they plan on preventing damage to the cables over such vast distances, or how the electromagnetic forces may fuck up some of the sea life.
The electromagnetic forces surrounding a 50 MW 1000 kV undersea power transmission cable are insignificant. If the cable is shielded by a copper mesh, no electric forces escape the cable, and at 50 amps (50 MW/1000 kV), the magnetic forces outside the cable are barely above Earth's ambient magnetic field. Right outside the cable, the magnetic field is 100 microTesla, which is considered harmless to all biological processes, and at 40 cm distance, it is already well below the Earth's ambient magnetic field of ~50 microTesla.
Suncable in Australia are doing something similar, or talking about it at least. 3800km from Australia to Singapore, via Indonesia
not sure it'll ever get up by who knows
It's a long fucking way though.
Thank you a discussion portion in this paper could have said something like this, there are some math I can do without thinking to hard but there are other I cannot.
Crazy that there isn’t one already.
Laws of physics be damned
Who has the time to concern themselves with silly things like losses and voltage drop these days anyway...
Why buy from Canada when Russia and the Middle East are right there?