Weird, my inbox only flagged this as new 6h later even though I've opened the app a lot...

I'm not saying they shouldn't pay it, I'm saying they shouldn't be denied the service they've paid for which is what the law is trying to do.

I disagree that hurricane insurance is a tax, but if we assume that's the case, then this law would in essence be, if your house is destroyed in a hurricane and you make $X we don't actually cover your house anymore.

I don't think that's right, and I disagree its a tax.

Edit: I guess my car insurance is a tax too by your view as it's mandatory and it's even you're required to get a minimum coverage from the province.

Edit: and I guess if it wasn't clear, I support them not paying it if they don't benefit because I disagree its a tax, but I think they should be required to pay it and benefit from it. If you want to tax them more, raise their taxes. The law is bad. They paid for insurance and deserve it.