Homelab

Change ISP

Main ISP is fiber, house is part of HOA that has cable internet included, so that is my failover.

Main is 2gbps symmetrical

Failover is 300 down, 10 up

Edgerouter 4 with 1 Gb symmetric fiber primary and cable 500/20 backup. Network is setup so most media devices that are down-only come through the backup so I have regular verification that it's functioning. Essentially two ports in the house supply separate networks, each with a dedicated outside line, but set up to fail over to the other outside line.

I thought they had completely dropped the Edgerouter line, but I just popped over and it looks like they're actually in stock and reasonably priced. If I had to replace the ER4, I'd probably go to an ER12, which as far as I can tell is an ER4 with a built in switch (the ER4 doesn't act as a switch between ports - each port has its own address space).

The only time my network is down is when the power is out

100% up time obviously

I have 5G LTE modem with unlimited data plan on UPS. It is not bad ISP here but power outages…

My router is x86 linux, so I can just usb tether to my phone like a frugal king.

I use an cheap EdgeRouterX to detect failover events then route all traffic out secondary WAN (Teltonika 4G) and I have a nice failover script where I get notified via pushover of the events.

One of those travel routers sharing the connection from my neighbors Xfinity Hotspot ($20/mnth) as my second uplink to my main fiber

Mikrotik do inexpensive routers and their RouterOS is wonderful.

It can even do connection-based load balancing over two connections, although I don't have the mastery to set this up yet.

A $30 GL.iNET Opal router tethered to my cell phone. Plugged a cable from a LAN port of the Opal to the WAN or WAN2 of my pfSense router.

If the Opal is plugged in WAN2 all the time you could have pfSense do automatic failover that is seamless.

Fail over? Cry and smoke some weed until it comes back on.

Unifi UDM PRO with a GL.iNet GL-X3000 (Spitz AX) 5G NR AX3000 Cellular Gateway Router for failover on the backup link. Separate providers for primary and backup. No MVNO.

We're almost in 2024. I've been on the Internet since 91. Today's telco/network equipment come with error reporting via alarms / data pushed to centralized tools that usually highlight issues. If your ISP is subpart and can't fix it's network, can't you switch to another ISP?

Also, have you done your homework and positive the issue doesn't come from any of your equipment? Why not open a ticket w/ the ISP with all the proof on hand? Are they aware?

If you've done all of that work, that they are aware and "sit & do nothing", it's fair to post the name of that ISP right here!

Firewalla. 🤷

A few days in the mountains

😭

Cox Cable modem (metered) and Verizon LTE load balanced with my firewall appliance.

Pen and paper.

2.5Gbps main uplink and 1Gbps failover uplink, pfsense, and a 5G wireless modem in case of emergency or nuclear fallout

I run dual 4G WAN anyway because of latency and bandwidth, failover was just a bonus.

I got like 2mbps on cable, and I'm pretty sure the line is now actually broken/severed (tree fell on it) and they just never bothered fixing it because nobody uses it anyway.

Wait, one’s supposed to have a network failover solution?

DSL main, cheap little LTE modem via USB as a fallback. Both are connected to my OPNsense as a gateway group. Failover happens after 5s of full packet loss (and a bunch of less aggressive failover conditions, latency etc.). That of course changes my public IPv4 address, so yes this drops existing connections. Not a big deal for most stuff, Netflix reconnects quickly enough that this isn't even noticeable. For the stuff where the connection can't drop like that, I run a VPN tunnel on each of the two uplinks to a small relay box with a static IP sitting in a datacenter. When DSL fails, the traffic is routed through the other VPN link but comes out of the relay box with the same public IP.

I have a Rutx12 router that has 2 cellular modems, if the WAN link fails it will route via 2 load balanced 4g connections. It works great in my hack rack and means my lab is completely mobile with no breaks in connectivity

Main fiber link with one ISP and cable modem with a different ISP. I'm lucky enough to live at an intersection where both options are available - and the two links are literally buried under two different roads.

5gbps fiber and then a 5G business internet backup failover via UniFi UDM-Pro, all on UPS with a standby Generac. We can take a power and ISP outage simultaneously and have a second or so connectivity hiccup.

I've got a dual-wan UXG-Pro and am lucky enough to have two 1Gbps providers (fiber + cable), plus an employer who reimburses me for both. I have a small wired T-Mobile LTE MiFi device as backup, but never needed it. ($20 a month + usage over 2GB)

I have a cheap hotspot that I use for fail over of a couple things like home automation and remote access. Not enough data to do a full fail over but keeping a couple things going is enough.

get a mikrotik they are good for the price and setup recursive routing so what I'm using right now is 2 wans or you could use 1 wan and 1 4g or plug a phone on the usb port and turn on usb tethering so basically recursive routing checks if a host is up on a line say isp 1 pings to see if 1.1.1.1 is up if not switch to isp 2 isp 1 is my own line and isp 2 is my apartment's shared internet connection that has unstable speeds but for failover, it's better than nothing

try increasing your speed. we had an issue once like this, turns out one of our systems was flooding the connection and it would reset. Once we increased the speed the bottleneck went away and it quit happening

pfSense virtual router connect to a FTTP NTD and a Huawei LTE 4G router

I've got two ISP connections that go to a Juniper SRX300, this is totally unnecessary and overkill but I got the router for free from work (I actually have a few of them).

Standard ISP and cradlepoint AER 3000 with Verizon and ATT back up

I don’t need failover at home. If I lose internet for a day, I’ll tether with my phone, go to a coffee shop or the office. Nothing in my homelab will die for lack of internet either

I have T-Mobiles Internet @Home, and CTL fiber both routed into my OpenWrt router, configured to do fail over

My primary is 200/200 fiber, and uses 5G as failover.

I host my VPN on a small vps, with nginx proxy manager, it routes my service’s back to my router using wireguard

My openwrt router is a Pi 4 operating as a “router on a stick” currently, I use an Aruba 2920 switch to achieve this but can also be done with usb Ethernet adapters.

I hear MicoTik has some good cheap hardware and is extremely powerful router capable of the same things at reasonable price, but my openwrt has worked for me for many years.

Your asking for redundancy. You plug in a second wan connection and configure a failover.

Xfinity now has a router with a 4G backup

https://www.xfinity.com/learn/internet-service/stormready

A Raspberry Pi with two network interfaces (one can be a USB-to-Ethernet or USB-to-WiFi adapter) can be set up as a failover router. Just write scripts to check the internet connectivity regularly and switch between connections as needed.

A pile of shame, consisting of all the books I bought and haven't read yet.

OPNsense running on a 4 port Protectli. I use 2 ports for WAN connections with load balancing. I have it set to failover to using just one if there is packet loss or high latency on the other.

I’ve wanted one for a long time but don’t have time to deploy it.

So no fall over for mine. 💀