this post was submitted on 19 Nov 2023
1 points (100.0% liked)

Photography

24 readers
1 users here now

A place to politely discuss the tools, technique and culture of photography.

This is not a good place to simply share cool photos/videos or promote your own work and projects, but rather a place to discuss photography as an art and post things that would be of interest to other photographers.

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
 

I am a semi pro photographer still with a lot to learn. I had a photoshoot recently where it all seemed to go wrong and I don’t know how to address it with the client.

This is a client I have worked for a lot in the past and they’re always happy with my work and rehire me for all their event photography.

They reached out saying they needed a lifestyle / headshot type shoot in their restaurant. This was split into two parts, one with a child and a food product and 5 different types of shots to get the 4 different type of shots with multiple food products. They gave me 1 hr to do the whole shoot.

I arrived an hour early to set up but client turned up 20 mins late. Then the restaurant didn’t have the correct food products for the shoot. There was no representative from head office just the two staff members to be in the shoot (not models)

We spent half an hour alone trying to sort the food products out and then I finally began shooting. 1st staff member was a reluctant model and it too a while to get her to relax by which time food product had melted and needed to be remade.

By the end, I was on site for two and a half hours, even though I was only being paid for 1 hour.

I’m not even happy to provide the client with the shots because they’re not good enough. (Client with eyes closed, blurred or product out of focus)

Currently, I’m thinking of sending the client what few shots I do have and explaining the issues but I don’t want to make it should like excuses for my lack of experience.

Do I write the whole shoot off and use it as a learning experience? I have definitely learned not to let the client dictate the time of a shoot.

top 50 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] Hantzell@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

You would be surprised how much ‘food’ photography is not food, or not fresh food. Among other things, it doesn’t melt

[–] aaffpp@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

It seems obvious you didn't send a project plan and the client did not circulate it. Chock this up to inexperience. You screwed up too. Don't blame the client. Don't charge. Suggest a reshoot.

[–] kneehighonagrasshopr@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

I would send what you have that are useable and tell them that you had little cooperation from the establishment/cooks/whatever. Tell them how long it took and suggest that you'll be adding additional hourly rates to your contract. Don't have one? Make one ASAP.

I have a feeling that you're being too hard on yourself. Usually when I feel shitty about a shoot it's generally because it didn't go as I envisioned but generally the photos are still good. Maybe not portfolio worthy but I'm sure the client will be happy with them if they've been happy with you in the past.

[–] Wooden-Quit1870@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Non model models and real food is definitely 2 issues that can torpedo a shoot by themselves.

[–] bubblechunksy@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Everything you’ve mentioned can be reshot. You don’t even need to wait for a sunny day!

[–] elviajedelviento@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago (7 children)

Might be the perfectionist in me, but I honestly don't understand how you can go professional, take on clients who pay for your work, when your product shots are blurry & out of focus. In my eyes, that's a lack of skill, not a lack of time.

I'm guessing you're not being paid much. (And undercutting the work of skilled, trained professionals.) In that case, I would say the client got what he paid for.

I'm sorry if this sounds harsh, it's nothing personal. Please do correct me if I'm wrong.

[–] slp203948@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

I think I was being a little self deprecating and having a moment of ‘imposter syndrome’. Not all of the shots are out of focus or blurry and I definitely have usable shots that I can provide to the client. But the ratio of out of focus to in focus is higher than I normally get on a shoot and I think this was down to all the other variables of having to sort the food and a time pressure. I have done many paid shoots to date with return clients so I don’t think I’m undercutting anyone however I think I undervalue myself and this is something else I need to work on.

[–] Significant_Amoeba34@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Sort of agreed. We all started somewhere, though.

[–] YungTaco94@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Sounds like you’re the “trained skilled professional” that’s getting undercut 🥴

[–] Danither@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Honestly your comment seems like your a pro that doesn't get job offers and is taking that out in comments here rather than a fair critique.

Depending on the situation and Model, it is completely normal to get out of focus shots I'd say in 1/10 photos. People move whilst the shutters open or AF has some latency at the wrong point. Even with the fastest shutterspeed you'll get some blur unless you have a high end pro camera/lighting. Which not all working photographers have. When shooting humans you can only control yourself and the camera.

If you've readjusted someone by having to walk to them because they don't understand. Then reset your position. This only is compounded by the fact you want to leave after they've made you late.

That's prime blur territory that is 😂

If all your photos are blurry however. That's different and you'd be correct

[–] flint_and_fable@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

I don’t do product or food photography but isn’t a lot of the op’s problems normally covered in the contract reqs? Starting on time, using models, etc? I know I go home if my engagement session couples are more than 15 min late. The shoot depends on lighting and unless we scheduled (and charged for) a night shoot I won’t have the gear on hand or an assistant there to help with it.

[–] CypherBear@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago (1 children)

I really do hate this undercutting talk, I've been seeing it for 20 years now and it's complete bs.

Take weddings for example; someone charging £400 for a wedding is not undercutting someone charging £2000 a wedding, because the person spending £400 on a wedding photographer likely couldn't afford £2000 for one.

There are different clients with different budgets. If this restaurant is paying a low cost photographer it is doubtful they'd pay someone twice the price to do the same thing.

I've done most types of photography, and still do a few subjects I enjoy like weddings. I've trained my wife up who is slowly taking over my business, it sounds like the OP folded under the pressure, if they've done previous jobs that have been fine.

As for your bakery analogy... Doesn't really work does it because you wouldn't sell the client the burnt ones, you'd bin them.

Your right they need to up their game, but things like this are great learning tools. I remember photoshopping a drain pipe from the top of someone's head when I first started because I hadn't noticed it. It taught me to fully check the background as well as the subject... That was 20 years ago. Mistakes are a great teacher.

[–] elviajedelviento@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago (1 children)

"If this restaurant is paying a low cost photographer it is doubtful they'd pay someone twice the price to do the same thing."

That's exactly what undercutting is, isn't it? But I get what you are saying, and you're right. Someone who can't afford to spend €500 on a designer purse will never buy the original one anyway. They will buy the retail dupe. But at the other hand, someone who is a fulltime professional and fully depends on it to make an income, will have costs, expenses, taxes, that a photographer who does a paid job here and there doesn't have. They háve to ask higher prices, for the same work. Because not all of them are in the luxury bracket of the market.

I guess it all depends on the situation, it's not that black & white. My undercutting comment was just an afterthought, that's why I put it in brackets.

The point of my comment was to express my genuine surprise at someone who seemingly lacks a basic beginner skill going professional. As I have already explained in another comment, I am only talking about that basic skill. Taking sharp photos of still objects. No matter de circumstance.

I am not talking about managing & leading shoots, setting up lighting, making contracts, directing models, dealing with client expectations. I am not talking about taking photos of moving objects, people, action, sports, animals, kids... I am not talking about the less technical, more intuitive skills of photography like composition, colour, background...

Which OP dóes seem to have talent for, or she wouldn't have paid work nor repeat customers.

Those are indeed learning curves, even for professionals.

If you say her shoot went wrong because of stress. Yes, of course it did. Of course you stress if you're taking on a job that you're not ready for. That's my whole point.

I stand by my bakery analogy. If you don't have the basic skill, knowing how to set up & time your oven so that the bread comes out right, don't go opening a bakery. Of course, mistakes happen, but I don't know any professional baker who regularly has to throw out half or more than half of his work because it came out inedible, do you?

[–] CypherBear@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago (1 children)

If your definition of undercutting is just working cheaper than anyone else, then aren't we all undercutting the guy charging the most? 🤣

For me and photography I'd likely say it's asking what someone else is charging and offering to do it for less. But I guess both are right in some sense.

I think what you're getting at is that being a professional photographer is only 15% about taking and editing photos and most people don't realise it's about so many different things, from advertising to accounting, from people management to handling stress. In which case you're spot on.

They were ready for the original job, just not experienced enough for the stressful situation. It's learning. Id have you laughing with the crap I've had to deal with over the years. And that only comes with experience which you can only get on the job. No one is ready for it until you've experienced it. I'm yet to have a bride or groom do a runner... That'll be interesting 🤣

Maybe I've just been around so long that first name last name photography with full kit worth less than I've paid for just on batteries or memory cards, no contracts, no insurance, just doesn't faze me any more. Theres a local girl to me who I've known for years who had started pushing it hard into the photography world, her images are all dark, out of focus and if I took them I'd think I'd just a stroke. She calls it a style, like that of the wedding photos and paid for at her wedding.

My wife is stressing about the competition, whereas I just laugh because she isn't. She'll likely not be around in a year like most others, including the girl who used a photo from a wedding where she was a guest to advertise her business.... It was my pose and I was half in the photo 🤣

[–] elviajedelviento@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

It's not my definition. It's literally what the word means.

undercutting/ˌʌndəˈkʌt/

  1. offer goods or services at a lower price than (a competitor)."these industries have been undercut by more efficient foreign producers (similar: charge less than charge a lower price than undersell)

(Definiton from Oxford languages on Google.)

As I said, if you are a fulltime pro, depending on the work to make a living, you'll have costs a "semi-pro" taking on a job once in a while doesn't have. Those might be a website, promotion budget, income taxes (!), professional quality equipment, a studio, printer + way too expensive ink & paper, office, assistant, accountant... You HAVE to ask higher prices, which clients might not be willing to pay, because a "semi-pro" can do it cheaper, with or without the same quality of work.

"The point of my comment was to express my genuine surprise at someone who seemingly lacks a basic beginner skill going professional. As I have already explained in another comment, I am only talking about that basic skill. Taking sharp photos of still objects. No matter de circumstance."

Thát is what I am getting at. Taking sharp photos of still objects. It's the first thing I learned when I took beginner photography classes. Learning how to control your camera settings (ISO, shutter speed, aperture) to take sharp photos of still objects. It's what you learn to do, in different circumstances, by training, not by going professional, taking people's money and inevitably messing up shoots because you're not ready for the job.

[–] SLPERAS@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

There are lot of issues with the shoot, but if your shots are, shots of client with eyes closed or blurry photos, that’s on you nothing to do with the client. Maybe explain what went wrong and make it seems like it’s kinda their fault and offer to reshoot with better planning next time.

[–] Dry-Wheel-6324@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago (1 children)

This is also a case of setting expectations for the client. An hour isn’t enough time for that if everything isn’t set and ready and it’s a new type of shot for you. I’d look at time stamps and see what you got in the time you were scheduled. Anything else is extra frankly

[–] slp203948@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

This has been a huge learning curve for me.

[–] NoHopeOnlyDeath@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago (2 children)

I'm not addressing the quality of the photos. Enough people in the thread have brought up the out of focus thing.

I will say, however, that if I'm contacted by a business owner to shoot them in their business, and then when I show up, the business is obviously not prepared for the shoot, that's not my problem.

If the shoot is for x, y, and z, and then the restaurant says "Oh sorry, we don't have the ingredients for x and y, and z is just gonna be this random employee who wasn't prepared for this.", that's the client's fault, and, honestly, I have a paragraph in my standard contract that covers shit like this.

[–] Vilenation@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Who wrote that contract! 💪

[–] nemezote@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago (1 children)

Mind sharing that paragraph?

[–] NoHopeOnlyDeath@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Elements of the shoot that are planned to be provided by the client (including but not limited to: client-owned business or other location, employees, props, etc) are provided at the sole discretion of the client and are not the responsibility of (insert business name here). Appointments that are unable to be completed due to these factors will be rescheduled at the client's discretion at the currently agreed hourly rate.

[–] SuperbWrap7846@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

I've had similar issues in my earlier days and they're always a learning curve. Given your relationship with the client and their past satisfaction, it's worth being transparent with them. Explain the challenges faced during the shoot (late arrival, unavailability of proper food products, unprepared staff, etc.) but do so professionally, without pointing fingers.

Now, about the photos - since you're not satisfied with the quality, it's better not to compromise your standard. But also maybe take a step back and re-evaluate the shoot - sometimes we can be a bit harsh on ourselves when coming off a situation like this and you might still have some decent shots you can use. If it's really not up to par then perhaps offer a re-shoot at a discounted rate, depending on your relationship with the client. This way, you're not just leaving them high and dry but providing a solution.

Above all else though, you've got the right idea about not letting clients dictate unrealistic timelines. Future shoots should have clear time allocations that consider setup, possible delays, and shooting time.

[–] scootifrooti@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

I'd put this more on them than yourself.

I'd let them know the shot was a bust due to said reasons, and it needs to be redone, correctly this time.

[–] l1v32r1d3BmX@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Seems like the planning stage of the photoshoot was skipped.. all of these issues wouldn’t have happened if you guys had a meeting beforehand to plan the shoot out/ make sure everyone and everything will be there ready to go when you get there. And unless you’re working with a big team, it’s on you to make sure it’s all set up.

Now as far as the bad shot:ratio that’s something that takes practice until it’s no longer an issue.

[–] tampawn@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago (1 children)

I'd take full responsiblity and explain to the client that it was your fault. You didn't explain the importance of having models there on time, and also the importance of having the food ready to go so you could get all the shots in that hour.

Don't share the shots you took.

He doesn't care about the shots you got unless you have ALL of the shots he wanted. So tell him let's reschedule when everyone has time and you 'and he' can coordinate the shoot better.

Tell him you did all you could with what you had but your goal is to get him quality shots for all the plates.

It sounds like it was a team effort and you weren't the leader you needed to be... He will respect your approach if you sell this right. And for the next shoot, if he agrees...show up early and dressed nice, have a plan for each shot, be super engaging to the models, and say how great the food looks often. Say please and thank you a LOT. In other words...make up for your fuck up.

[–] flint_and_fable@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago (1 children)

op already said they were an hour early and I wouldn’t presume to tell someone to dress nice in a professional setting (and assume they don’t). Bit overkill. Sounds like talking down “say thank you and please little jimmy”

[–] tampawn@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago (1 children)

Flint you're too sensitive. Its time to man up when a man screws up. Not be a defensive pussy. If it sounds like you're being talked down to, then you're not realizing what the customer thinks of you because you were paid and didnt deliver.

OP's showing up early didn't help did it? Next time make sure your settings are right so your photos are in focus as part of your earliness.

If I know I'm going to be late I wear a tie. When I say dress nice I mean don't wear a nicer t-shirt like you haha. I'm not saying be a simp...I'm saying be respectful with pleases and thank yous.

I've shot more than 500 events and had a few fuckups along the way and I know how to best resolve them by satisfying the customer...what about you,little Jimmy?

[–] flint_and_fable@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago (1 children)

Lmao thanks for the entertainment. If I’m late I wear a ball gown. It makes everything better. 💃You’re never going to convince me you were hired 500 times, you’re just a try hard.

[–] tampawn@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago (1 children)

more than 500 because I do what I say and say what I'm gonna do...and I don't let people down. Half my business is repeat business. If I fuck up I make up for it...jimmy!

Just keep wearing your tshirt and underwhelming your peeps...

[–] flint_and_fable@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago (1 children)

Nahhh. I’d rather hire a chill guy in jeans and a tshirt over you and your obnoxious personality. Can’t sell me the story is real. Loud mouth bc you have a lot to prove and little going on. Good luck out there champ.

[–] tampawn@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago (1 children)

Yeah you go your way I'll go mine, FandF... I'm betting your going to have to get the last word...bring the snark biotch!

[–] flint_and_fable@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Uh. Wow. I don’t think I have to, with those replies you are your own worst enemy.

[–] Soupdumplingaddict@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

I would give it to her for free if the shots aren’t good and apologise. I never set a time for product / food photography because you never know how long it will take, I just say a rough estimation and set the price based on the number of photos purchased

[–] Jeff_with_a_J@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Next time you face a situation like this it’s ok to offer a re-scheduling even if you’re 100% setup and ready. The client wasn’t ready and unprofessional by showing up late and not communicating to whomever the necessary dishes that were required. One thing you can do in a situation like this is start working with the models to put them at ease. Even if there isn’t any food, you can still do the shoot as if there is and bring the food in after, re-shoot or even shoot it without the talent. But definitely walk away from something like this before it gets worse. And communicate.

[–] dkjb14@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

One thing I've learnt from food photography is you make 3 copies of the food. Always. Use hair spray. Shoot humans and food separately. Compose them in post.

Early on in my career I used to shoot for 5 star hotels. I'm glad I moved on

[–] ColinCool4691@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Offer a free one off reshoot then tell them similar bookings will be on a $/£/€ per hour basis with a 30 min overshoot thrown in for goodwill (actually to keep their business as the client is always right), and anything over is charged at the hourly rate. If the company are decent they'll think you've made a special allowance for this job and rebook you. If they're ***holes to work for then you're better off without them.

[–] LyLyV@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Your first mistake was agreeing to do so many shots in 1 hour, but I'm sure you realize that by now.

When I worked in a commercial advertising studio (as an photo assistant, set stylist, and graphic designer), food shoots were a half- to full-day project (depending on the client), using stand-in food while the stylist made the 'hero' food look presentable. These shoots for well-known fast food restaurant menu boards and didn't even including any models.

Can you do it in less time? Maybe. But this was for a single shot of [whatever type of sandwich] plus creative directors from the ad agency coming in & out to oversee everything. The food styling itself took hours to get right (separately-paid professional), and then you have get the shot in a few minutes before it goes bad. Model shoots with a product like exercise equipment were often equally time consuming.

Sure, you can squeeze in a couple of shots in a half day, but you're on location (we never did food shoots on location) and you're talking multiple models and multiple food products... and you agreed to do all that in 1 hour? That's just craziness, IMO.

Someone already mentioned preparation. All of this could've been solved in advance with a meeting to discuss creative direction for each shot and how much preparation each shot would require.

Hopefully you get a chance to re-shoot this, and hopefully you are able to explain tactfully how expectations went wrong all-around. It would be nice if you could actually get paid for all the time it takes to do what you set out to do. Good luck!

[–] Sad-File3624@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Honesty is the only way forward.

Now to you learning something from all this.

First of, you should not have started shooting without the client present. Second, food photography is one of the hardest to get right. Most great food photography does not include actual foodstuffs. Third, use this as a learning experience. Never accept a job without knowing you’ll be able to achieve it.

How did you handle lighting for the foodstuff? On camera flash? Strobes? Did you have an assistant so they could move things while you stood behind the lens and guided them?

[–] TittysForScience@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Offer to reshoot for free

[–] Huge-Ad-3757@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Stop charging/accepting 1 hour gigs! Charge half day rates or full day rates!!

[–] Reasonable_ginger@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Half day rate minimum

[–] Maaatosone@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago
[–] Reworked@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

I'm going to disagree with half of the thread on one point - taking good photos while trying to navigate this clusterfuck is going to be extremely difficult, this kind of baffling shit would have anyone off their game. They didn't do their part, on any front. Your images probably aren't acceptable quality but if you're in any way involved in sorting out personnel issues or supply issues for the things they're supposed to be providing things have gone terminally sideways anyway.

In your shoes I'd offer to schedule a reshoot at a discount - depending on how good they've been in the past, potentially comped - with the note to them that the organization needs to be WAY better for the second round. I'd consider working on your scheduling and setting expectations more than fretting over the quality of work; if it's big enough that you're scheduling an hour of setup, it's probably more than an hour of session time. If it's an hour of session time that a commercial client is a third of the window late for, the discussion should probably be on a serious discussion of extending the billed time or rescheduling because that's just kinda wild to me.

The bit about the reluctant model is enough to make me think that the company needs a good hard whack on the subject of professionalism and what preparing for a photo shoot actually means because that is *so* not your job to deal with, either. They shouldn't be forcing someone into a photo shoot that they don't want to be a part of.

[–] Digitai5@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Link him this reddit post

[–] hotrodguru@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

I quit reading after "they gave me 1 hr". You need to dictate how much time is needed for the scope of work.

[–] kaffie27@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Oh yeah, this happens to the best of us. Yes, follow up with what you told us here, offer to retake, but you'll need to be paid for your time. It's hard to stand up for yourself sometimes, but give it a try. Be ready with a written list of how you can make the next shoot run smoother.

One hour for all the takes they wanted is unreal. I was once given 10 MINUTES to shoot a super busy company president. I was sweating. I did a few mugs in her office, then literally followed her to her next appointment, shooting her walking towards me, then away, and briefly chatting with her staff on the way.

Turned out pretty cool for a story on her work as president of a busy non-profit.

Oddly enough, there were shoots I did where I thought none of the photos were very good. Then the client would call and rave about how awesome the photos were. Go figure.

Chin up, you can't nail them all. If they drop you over one bad shoot, and I've had that happen, move on. It used to crush me, but at least I learned something each time, and it polished me up and made me better.

[–] Nick__Nightingale__@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Try and make it right with them. Keep it collaborative with the client so they feel involved to correct the shoot. It happens a lot when you first start out. Just always try and salvage what you can and learn from it. Standards of practice are super helpful but those things take time to build up.

[–] Snoggeramus@alien.top 1 points 11 months ago

Tech the client about what is involved in doing it properly.

Don't let the client dictate that it's only an hour of work as things are magic in their minds and you don't need to be subsidising that.

Further, the client being late and unorganised simply did not deliver on what would be reasonably expected of them.