he can be, but what i need to see is something he has shown this year
which is the midrange game, this year he's on fire, historically speaking he's been bad, so he has to continue it
for me, it's kinda what has stopped a lot of two way scoring players from being capital S superstars, because when it comes time to win, teams take away threes and the paint, can you get a shot that you can make 45-50% of the time when that happens?
it's why KD/Kawhi have been a tier above PG this whole last era
PG could always create the midrange shot, but never really made it, meanwhile those two were making like 50% of theirs
i'm not, i just don't give double credit for all nba + all defense
PG is all nba BECAUSE he's a good offensive player and a great defensive player
if he was just his offense, he's not an all nba player
only some players in nba history are just all nba based purely on their offense or defense, PG isn't one of them, he's there because he's good on both ends