No way you have Sengun beneath Cam Thomas
this post was submitted on 25 Nov 2023
1 points (100.0% liked)
NBA - Main
14 readers
1 users here now
Game analysis, highlights and everything else that is happening in the NBA.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
He has RJ Barrett above Banchero and Wagner. Let him cook lol
Dam I am definitely taking Lamelo top 5 if I had a choice..l
Josh giddy is at least top 15
No comment
He definitely likes them 23 and under
Give or take 4 years
Giddey is 17 tops
What’s your reasoning for having Herro over the 8-10 guys?
That’s the major one that I’m like what the fuck
Lamelo is better than chet
Considering he just turned 20 (guy is a full year younger than Brandon Miller and the Thompson twins that were drafted this year) Shaedon Sharpe should sneak in.
Mobley slightly too high, LaMelo too low, Cam is comically high and probably shouldn’t even be on the list, Sengun is way too low, Barrett being on the list is hilarious, Paolo too low
Rj is better than cam rn but not better than Franz or Paolo
Neither should be on this list lol
Herro over Barnes?
Yo Op this is wild. I’d have Sengun at 3 legitimately
Ant should probably be number one if you're using your own guidlines
Ant man is 1
The absolute disrespect to put the Magic duo under Barrett of all people
This list is straight ass lmao
On god lmao
RJ is better than franz stop w that 😂
I want a legit reason why Hali is better than Ant and I love Hali.
The only thing Hali will have on him is playmaking and efficiency but Ant has been efficient himself and is a great defender
As a Pacers fan I agree. Ant’s overall game is more valuable and the only way Hali stays above him is if he maintains 25 and 12 on 50/40/90 AND becomes an average defender, which I think he can cause of his size and basketball IQ but he’s sadly shown no signs of progress in that department.
I don’t really care who goes over who, but “only” playmaking is ignoring how massive that gap is.
PPG wise Haliburton is at 25.4 PPG today Vs 26.7 for Edwards
APG wise, Hali is currently at 12.1 APG vs 5.1 for Edwards, over doubling his total there.
Efficiency wise, Hali has been even more efficient than Edwards too. Ant is definitely the better defender which needs to be factored in, but statistically I don’t think there’s much argument so far this year Hali has been a better offensive player
I’d like to point out here that Ant is being hounded by doubles every game now. So, yes, Hali’s efficiency is higher, but it’s obviously a bit easier scoring and moving the ball 1v1 than 1v2.
Despite the doubles, his splits are still roughly 46/38/87, which are obviously still good despite the insane attention.
Mobley is not that good he's the same dude for years. I never knew people cared about defense in Cleveland that much
Listing players who didn't play even fucking 20 games is disrespectful as hell to the others on the list.
I don't care how wembenyama or chet looks good or their ceiling. They did not play at least a half of a season.
These lists are dumb cause some people are so closely ranked, they will never get these lists right
Tier lists are the way to go
Lamelo not top 10 is crazy tho.
Tbh this list is a joke. Sengun is safely top 5, maybe top 3. Herro is a bit high. RJ Barrett is a bit too high
You lack vision
considers all components of the game: offense, rebounding, passing, efficiency, defense
3. Tyrese Maxey
boy, this is...something
Franz, Banchero and Sengun need to be way higher
Sengun way too low
This list is horrible lol
Wtf is cam Thomas doing here
Would you rather have Herro or Sct Brn on your team? lol
Coby white is unironically better than Giddey
I’d put Giddey at 17, hopefully no lower but you never know
Cam Thomas over Sengun??? Lmfao
Sengun should be at worst 6th on this list
I will not stand for this Kegan Murray erasure. Dude set the rookie record for most three pointers made and has turned into a very positive (dare I say elite?) defender.
There’s like MAYBE one dude you have ranked over LaMelo that’s actually better than him lol