Very useful site. Thanks for posting this.
Technology
This is a most excellent place for technology news and articles.
Our Rules
- Follow the lemmy.world rules.
- Only tech related news or articles.
- Be excellent to each other!
- Mod approved content bots can post up to 10 articles per day.
- Threads asking for personal tech support may be deleted.
- Politics threads may be removed.
- No memes allowed as posts, OK to post as comments.
- Only approved bots from the list below, this includes using AI responses and summaries. To ask if your bot can be added please contact a mod.
- Check for duplicates before posting, duplicates may be removed
- Accounts 7 days and younger will have their posts automatically removed.
Approved Bots
Your browser accepts cookies. Websites can write small files to your device that persist after you leave — files that identify you when you return, that follow you across sites, that remember what you looked at, what you almost bought, and how long you hesitated. We have not written one. Your browser would let this page write up to 10 GB to your device — a private room, ours alone, like the one given to every site you visit.
Hol up ... 10 GB?
I think that refers to localStorage not cookies.
It got my location wrong. It got my GPU wrong. It said I never left the tab, even though I left it to start this comment. It said I moved my cursor 111 times in 74 seconds, which is absolutely false.
That site is just pointless. Pretty much the only things it got right were my time zone and my browser.
Ridiculously accurate forme, tried across multiple browsers.
Gyro, screensize, battery are all causes for concern. I have firefox with ublock and ss and it was able to see all except the gpu and battery.
In my case it was incredibly accurate, except for one detail; the wire said I moved my finger over 600 times which... Seems hyperbolic.
It also says I have Azerbaijani on my phone somewhere. I have no idea where that came from.
That's actually usually a sign of malware...
That's a good point. Thanks for that. Any tips on how to narrow down on that?
You can download Hypatia. It's a malware scanner. There's an official fork that kept it alive after the original dev stopped maintaining.
Otherwise, you'd have to narrow it down further. Any non mainstream apps you have would be the first to check
Awesome. Thanks.
It says I'm on Chrome, I'm not.
Also, so what if you know my IP, that isn't sensitive information.
It's good to bring attention to this stuff but at the same time there's no point getting too worried about it.
Fingerprinting is real and we know it. Not because of the site but because every software dev I know who works in a net startup tells me that they do the basics and more. They won't talk about the more.
What are you using? Firefox?
The website is clearly AI-slopped, what did you expect?
Heheh, a whole lot of mocking in this thread, but I don't mind the site / its display.
Yeah, it's overly melodramatic in its setup, and a bunch of the information doomerism is silly in terms of the info basically being required to provide data comms etc. It also tends to get things a bit wrong in a few categories -- like for me, it said I was in a totally different city (still the right country at least - Canada), then it said my time zone was in iceland, which is kinda... no.
But the general message of the site, and the awareness its trying to raise in regards to how much data gets shared for basic comms establishment, and how that information gets used to fingerprint people, is worthwhile.
It got the country wrong for me. I didn't use a VPN or anything. So that's good I guess.
Time zone has no info about where I actually am. Sure, I'm in a particular vertical slice of the earth. I have the JP keyboard downloaded, but you're wrong, that doesn't mean I speak Japanese. In fact, I speak French but your cookie reading didn't pick that up.
It is genuinely interesting what info gets passed to websites but the doomy tone is rather silly and will unnecessarily worry people who don't know much about computers/Internet, which is the majority of users.
It got my timezone and location pretty spot on, though.
My time zone is quite specific and has only about 500,000 people in it
Assuming it’s tz database timezones then they can be relatively specific. Since the slices are based around laws governing current time, there’s hundreds of slices rather than just a couple dozen. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_tz_database_time_zones Alongside things like keyboard downloaded it means you can be uniquely fingerprinted (or close to unique) pretty easily, which means they can then associate all sorts of other information with you
I opened it in Firefox and Librewolf just to see how the information sent was different. Librewolf obfuscated the following which Firefox disclosed:
Time zone
Monitor resolution
GPU used
Also, the Firefox one said I moved my cursor such-and-such times, while the Librewolf one said my finger moved such-and-such times. Must be related to hiding what screen I'm using. I'm on desktop.
Firefox on mobile obscured GPU.
"Your browser masked your graphics processor. Firefox and Safari have started returning generic strings — "Mozilla", "Apple", "or similar" — instead of the real renderer. The fact that yours did so tells us, with reasonable confidence, which browser you are running. The mask is also a fingerprint."
Is this just lack of dedicated GPU on mobile?
Uh no, my mobile phone, its just hidden what SoC I have
They're really playing up the ominous tone.
"We know this because your IP address — xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx — was the first thing your device sent us. We know the rest of it. We chose not to display it. Most pages would not have made that choice. We did not ask for your location. Your address arrived before you did."
Uh, yeah. That's how IP addresses work.
dude be careful, right now your house is probably broadcasting a street address.
the mailman that drops your mail off? he knows
Language and dark mode setting are also funny. Yes, I literally want to share those preferences so you don't serve me a blinding white website in hebrew. What a hacker you are.
We sent a SYN-ACK packet and YOU acknowledged it, confirming you are not spoofing YOUR IP address. Now WE share the same sequence number. Most sites do not tell you this is happening.
Compare this to Google's homepage, which is clean, wholesome, friendly, and inviting.
(I don't mind sites that try to scare the user straight, but this one definitely has the unmistakable tinge of AI-generated wording. Make a sense if you click through the links at the bottom to see who created it.)
It really looks ai-generated. It even contains mistakes like saying that my 5yo phone model with low resolution is a high end device. All the text is pretty "generic" and sloppy
It doesn't look AI generated. It's more likely that they wrote different text templates for different resolution ranges.
There are multiple sites like this, for example clickclickclick.click has been around for 10 years (not optimized for mobile)
Laughing my ass off reading through this. The sanctimonious and passive aggressive threatening tone is perfect for how much info it got wrong just because I use Firefox and an adblock. YOUR BROWSER DIDN'T TELL US ANYTHING ABOUT THIS, LIKELY BECAUSE ITS FIREFOX. BUT THAT MEANS WE KNOW YOU USE FIREFOX AND WE ARE CHOOSING TO BE SAFE WITH THAT INFO, YOURE WELCOME, PWNED!!!11!1111!1
Teaching people about fingerprinting and how important understanding it is for personal privacy is good, but acting like a 4chan script kiddy group and making bizarre empty threats like you're mr robot ain't it, dawg.
From other comments this is likely some AI slop to sell a product, but if they're serious they come off like they just slept through sec+ and think they're shadow brokers now lmao
On a bog standard phone with dns blocking and nothing more, it was able to identify a lot of information. Some pieces of information I didn't realize are sent to websites when I visit them. It's a good demonstration of fingerprinting.
This is lame as shit. The tone of the writing is going to get non-tech people feeling quite dismissive, or scared enough to seek out surface level info, which just rolls back into feeling dismissive. It's actually really stupid because they're clearly driving fear, but hardly touch the real thing to be scared of. Fingerprinting is barely mentioned, it's only really addressed once, in the font identification section. The issue with all these data points is how they can be collected and correlated across the web - it basically means fuck-all if it's only from one page.
edit: On top of that, each data point is presented as some sort of horrible catastrophe, when some are completely benign. Barely addressing why some points actually matter, or not at all. (Like click/touch data, it's needed for site functionality, but it gets creepy when that data is used for things like psychological profiling)
Even more disappointing because the formatting/appearance is more than clean enough to share with basically anyone. Yet the tone and focus makes that out of the question. What a waste of time to make this.
Didn't realize my phone sent it's rotation data without promoting, everything else is kind of needed to send me info.
My IP
My screen size
My interactions with the page
Doesn't seem to be anything new here than what's we already know:
Just with a more ominous tone. Is it any wonder people are afraid of technology?
sooooo reading a browsers user-agent is now a thing to worry about? oh look I changed my user-agent and now this dumb ass site is giving all the wrong info woulda look at that.
"We know where you are based on your IP" yeah bro, that's how IP's work. look i turned on mullvad, omg now it says i'm in Sweden!
"we know you're using an AMD gpu" gasp ya don't say. oh look I changed my user-agent again and now you think I'm on nvidia, crazy how that works huh?
This is a dumb bullshit site.
oh look it's built by these morons: https://riseuplabs.app/ a company that vibe codes every "product" they have. so naturally building a stupid site that just pulls your user-agent would seem amazing to them.
This is bullshit marketing for their bullshit vibe coding. report this post, it's an ad.
Your graphics processor identified itself as or similar.
Ah yes, Or similar, great GPU, love it.
Your finger moved 273 times. You tapped 14 times.
I'm sorry what?
Since they went into the effort to make this sound so ominous, it'd be cool to see some actual inferences from the data points. For example it would be pretty easy to tell you are behind a VPN and your real location is probably xyz.