I feel like they take some well framed and pretty, but also irrelevant images
They feel irrelevant to you. They may feel the same about some of your photos, while you may consider them to be your best work. What makes someone enjoy a photograph will vary wildly from person to person.
What makes a good photo indeed? I look at Henri Cartier-Bresson photos and some of them just don't do anything for me.
And sometimes, I see a shot with 10 likes from some anonymous guy on Flickr and consider it an absolute masterpiece.
And then there are photos that no one would look at twice, weren't it for the context they're inserted in. Some photos stand alone. Some photos owe their meaning and value to a bigger context.
There is no objective criteria to decide what a good photo is, especially from an artistic standpoint. I think this is a very important fact to internalize for any artist, photographer or otherwise.
I fully agree. I don't get it either.
Sure, this guy, for example. Now it's so obvious. But the first time I looked at the photos in my phone, he totally fooled me.